Sliding 7d Backtest — NO vs YES стратегии

N сделок
7,875
Stake
$787,500
NO P&L / ROI
$-107,067
-13.60%
YES P&L / ROI
$-51,948
-6.60%
Активных дней
53 / 201
Период цен
2025-09-22 19:41:04 → 2026-04-17 17:41:37
Источники
Mithilss + LuciferForge
(см. JSON)
Fee
4% × 2 (round-trip)

📊 Сравнение стратегий

Вывод: YES-стратегия убыточна меньше (P&L -51,948 vs NO -107,067), но всё равно минус.
Fee 4% × 2 = 8% round-trip съедает любой edge меньше 8%. Средний дневной P&L обеих стратегий отрицательный.

Источники данных (объединено в DuckDB): Gap: ноябрь 2025 — март 2026 (4 месяца без цен) — НЕ покрыт ни одним публичным источником.
⚠️ Обе стратегии убыточны. NO ROI = -13.60%, YES ROI = -6.60%. Fee 4%×2=8% на round-trip съедает любой edge меньше 8%.

1. Кумулятивный P&L (NO vs YES)

cumulative

2. Дневной P&L (grouped bars)

daily P&L

3. N сделок в день

N markets

4. Дневной ROI %

ROI

Красная пунктирная линия: порог 8% fee. Любой edge меньше 8% убыточен после fee.

5. Win rate %

WR

6. ROI по категориям (NO vs YES)

categories

7. WR NO vs WR YES (по категориям, размер = N)

WR scatter

Категории (NO + YES стратегии)

КатегорияN P&L NOROI NOWR NO P&L YESROI YESWR YES
crypto3,347-39,025-11.66%44.5%-39,840-11.90%55.2%
sports2,767-34,355-12.42%41.7%-6,312-2.28%48.8%
other1,084-15,327-14.14%41.4%-4,260-3.93%48.3%
weather227-13,000-57.27%19.8%+1,768+7.79%80.2%
politics187-1,192-6.37%48.1%-775-4.15%48.7%
geopolitics107-433-4.04%46.7%-2,424-22.65%51.4%
pop_culture62-1,952-31.48%12.9%+512+8.26%85.5%
entertainment37-842-22.76%32.4%+41+1.11%67.6%
science_tech29-729-25.13%24.1%-136-4.70%37.9%
economics28-214-7.64%60.7%-522-18.65%17.9%

По дням (NO + YES стратегии)

ДатаN P&L NOROI NOWR NO P&L YESROI YESWR YES
2025-09-2813+888+68.33%69.2%-537-41.34%30.8%
2025-09-2951-429-8.41%31.4%-451-8.85%66.7%
2025-09-3054-767-14.21%44.4%-228-4.23%51.9%
2025-10-0324-522-21.74%50.0%-172-7.16%50.0%
2025-10-0421-150-7.13%57.1%-186-8.87%42.9%
2025-10-058+186+23.24%62.5%-453-56.65%37.5%
2025-10-081+29+28.67%100.0%-102-102.29%0.0%
2025-10-1015+8+0.55%53.3%-183-12.18%46.7%
2025-10-11193-2,359-12.22%40.9%-3,119-16.16%59.1%
2025-10-12236-5,674-24.04%36.9%+762+3.23%61.9%
2025-10-13466-7,586-16.28%34.5%+5,317+11.41%62.0%
2025-10-14568-13,419-23.62%34.9%+2,018+3.55%59.3%
2025-10-15296-6,092-20.58%38.9%-2,275-7.68%55.4%
2025-10-16298-3,038-10.20%47.0%-5,232-17.56%51.7%
2025-10-17397-8,660-21.81%39.0%-3,462-8.72%57.9%
2025-10-18328-3,069-9.36%49.1%-2,302-7.02%48.2%
2025-10-19333-1,949-5.85%46.5%-5,300-15.92%51.6%
2025-10-20611-16,782-27.47%36.0%+1,563+2.56%61.5%
2025-10-21539-2,187-4.06%46.8%-7,450-13.82%49.7%
2025-10-22434-3,121-7.19%42.4%-5,383-12.40%55.3%
2025-10-23417-7,112-17.05%42.2%-2,776-6.66%54.7%
2025-10-24806-10,207-12.66%39.2%-6,893-8.55%51.5%
2025-10-25364-1,781-4.89%36.5%-3,983-10.94%46.4%
2025-10-26169-243-1.44%50.3%-2,182-12.91%42.6%
2025-10-27339-4,450-13.13%42.8%-1,339-3.95%46.6%
2025-10-28222-4,515-20.34%41.9%+632+2.84%50.5%
2025-10-29249-584-2.35%47.0%-3,148-12.64%42.6%
2025-10-3085-61-0.71%50.6%-1,033-12.16%37.6%
2025-10-3117+217+12.76%58.8%-464-27.28%23.5%
2026-03-1822+340+15.47%54.5%+272+12.37%40.9%
2026-03-199-193-21.50%77.8%-447-49.65%22.2%
2026-03-2014-313-22.39%64.3%+119+8.52%35.7%
2026-03-216-155-25.82%16.7%-20-3.42%66.7%
2026-03-2212-429-35.76%50.0%+308+25.68%50.0%
2026-03-235-253-50.69%40.0%+1,096+219.26%60.0%
2026-03-2476-146-1.91%72.4%-2,334-30.72%26.3%
2026-03-2518-383-21.28%72.2%+26+1.46%27.8%
2026-03-267-242-34.52%57.1%-274-39.15%42.9%
2026-03-279-256-28.50%66.7%+28+3.14%33.3%
2026-03-2811+5+0.46%54.5%-510-46.36%45.5%
2026-03-295-206-41.14%60.0%-292-58.41%40.0%
2026-03-306+30+5.01%83.3%-348-58.05%16.7%
2026-03-319-169-18.78%77.8%-326-36.19%22.2%
2026-04-018+75+9.34%75.0%-636-79.50%12.5%
2026-04-024-108-26.91%50.0%-18-4.44%25.0%
2026-04-0311-217-19.76%45.5%+538+48.91%54.5%
2026-04-045+35+6.99%80.0%-176-35.19%20.0%
2026-04-0526-237-9.12%61.5%-711-27.34%38.5%
2026-04-0614-225-16.09%71.4%+422+30.16%21.4%
2026-04-0711-200-18.18%63.6%-401-36.46%36.4%
2026-04-089-130-14.44%55.6%+883+98.08%33.3%
2026-04-0910-53-5.26%80.0%-469-46.92%10.0%
2026-04-1014-209-14.91%64.3%-316-22.58%28.6%
2025-09-22
2025-09-23
2025-09-24
2025-09-25
2025-09-26
2025-09-27
2025-10-01
2025-10-02
2025-10-06
2025-10-07
2025-10-09
2025-11-01
2025-11-02
2025-11-03
2025-11-04
2025-11-05
2025-11-06
2025-11-07
2025-11-08
2025-11-09
2025-11-10
2025-11-11
2025-11-12
2025-11-13
2025-11-14
2025-11-15
2025-11-16
2025-11-17
2025-11-18
2025-11-19
2025-11-20
2025-11-21
2025-11-22
2025-11-23
2025-11-24
2025-11-25
2025-11-26
2025-11-27
2025-11-28
2025-11-29
2025-11-30
2025-12-01
2025-12-02
2025-12-03
2025-12-04
2025-12-05
2025-12-06
2025-12-07
2025-12-08
2025-12-09
2025-12-10
2025-12-11
2025-12-12
2025-12-13
2025-12-14
2025-12-15
2025-12-16
2025-12-17
2025-12-18
2025-12-19
2025-12-20
2025-12-21
2025-12-22
2025-12-23
2025-12-24
2025-12-25
2025-12-26
2025-12-27
2025-12-28
2025-12-29
2025-12-30
2025-12-31
2026-01-01
2026-01-02
2026-01-03
2026-01-04
2026-01-05
2026-01-06
2026-01-07
2026-01-08
2026-01-09
2026-01-10
2026-01-11
2026-01-12
2026-01-13
2026-01-14
2026-01-15
2026-01-16
2026-01-17
2026-01-18
2026-01-19
2026-01-20
2026-01-21
2026-01-22
2026-01-23
2026-01-24
2026-01-25
2026-01-26
2026-01-27
2026-01-28
2026-01-29
2026-01-30
2026-01-31
2026-02-01
2026-02-02
2026-02-03
2026-02-04
2026-02-05
2026-02-06
2026-02-07
2026-02-08
2026-02-09
2026-02-10
2026-02-11
2026-02-12
2026-02-13
2026-02-14
2026-02-15
2026-02-16
2026-02-17
2026-02-18
2026-02-19
2026-02-20
2026-02-21
2026-02-22
2026-02-23
2026-02-24
2026-02-25
2026-02-26
2026-02-27
2026-02-28
2026-03-01
2026-03-02
2026-03-03
2026-03-04
2026-03-05
2026-03-06
2026-03-07
2026-03-08
2026-03-09
2026-03-10
2026-03-11
2026-03-12
2026-03-13
2026-03-14
2026-03-15
2026-03-16
2026-03-17

Метод: для каждого рынка с endDate в [start, max_ts-7d] вычисляется 7d-окно [endDate-7d, endDate]. Entry = последняя YES-цена ПЕРВОГО дня с ценами в окне. Exit = последняя YES-цена ПОСЛЕДНЕГО дня с ценами в окне. NO-стратегия: long NO по цене 1−entry, продажа по 1−exit. YES-стратегия: long YES по entry, продажа по exit. Fee 4% × 2. Каждый рынок учитывается ОДИН раз.